Skip to main content

The Mike Trout trade discourse has resurfaced among Phillies fans as Angels collapse

It's finally time to pull the trigger.
Sep 6, 2018; Philadelphia, PA, USA; Philadelphia Eagles tight end Zach Ertz (86) greets Angles outfielder Mike Trout before a game against the Atlanta Falcons at Lincoln Financial Field. Mandatory Credit: Bill Streicher-Imagn Images
Sep 6, 2018; Philadelphia, PA, USA; Philadelphia Eagles tight end Zach Ertz (86) greets Angles outfielder Mike Trout before a game against the Atlanta Falcons at Lincoln Financial Field. Mandatory Credit: Bill Streicher-Imagn Images | Bill Streicher-Imagn Images

Philadelphia Phillies fans have long dreamed of adding local kid Mike Trout to his hometown team, and there’s no time like the present to add a capable right-handed bat to a lineup in desperate need of just that.

The Los Angeles Angels are once again among the worst teams in all of baseball, and Trout is finally healthy and playing at an elite level. There are some substantial obstacles to getting a deal done, but Phillies fans would dance in the streets if it came to fruition.

Mike Trout’s .292/.406/.567 career line and 416 home runs make him a Hall of Fame lock whenever he’s done playing. At 34 years old he’s still going strong with an .877 OPS over 50 games so far this year.

Unfortunately, injuries have piled up in recent years, and the once-dependable centerfielder has topped 100 games played in a season just twice over the past six years.

On top of the availability concerns, the 16-year veteran is still owed $148.5 million over the next four years. If anyone can remain productive into his late-thirties it’s Mike Trout, but the possibility that injury woes turn his contract into a complete albatross looms large.

That’s what makes a Trout trade so tricky, as it would be foolish for the Halos to ship out a franchise legend for little more than salary relief. Conversely, it’s unlikely that an acquiring team would part with significant prospect capital for an aging veteran who is getting paid a ton and has injury concerns.

On top of all that, Trout holds 10-and-5 rights, which allow him to veto any trade, adding yet another barrier. Unless someone involved gets downright desperate to make a deal, the Millville Meteor is likely stuck in Anaheim for the foreseeable future.

It's hard to envision Mike Trout being traded, but if any team can do it, it should be the Phillies

And yet, there is one team that may be in the perfect position to pull off such a stunning trade. Embattled Phillies president of baseball operations Dave Dombrowski has been no stranger to massive contracts, shelling out nine-figure deals to Kyle Schwarber, Trea Turner, Zack Wheeler, Nick Castellanos (shudder), and others in recent years. Principal team owner John Middleton seems to have tightened the pursestrings a bit recently, but if there’s any player that has proven himself worthy of “stupid money”, it’s Mike Trout.

The Phillies have the financial might to absorb Trout’s massive contract, which gives them plenty of leverage to take on more of his remaining salary and lower the prospect cost. Shedding Taijuan Walker and Nick Castellanos’ dead money after this season opens up a world of possibilities, and there are few more exciting ways to reallocate those dollars than to a local superstar.

That brings up the second positive sign for a potential Phillies/Mike Trout union: there’s probably no place he’d rather go to than Philadelphia. Having grown up about an hour away from the City of Brotherly Love, Trout remains an avid Eagles fan and is frequently spotted in front-row seats at the Linc. Uprooting a comfortable life that he’s built over the past decade-and-a-half may be unappealing, but that discomfort can be partly assuaged by the prospect of heading home.

Last but not least, what could convince the Angels to part with the greatest gift God has given them since their 2002 World Series victory? Mike Trout has been the one constant throughout years of misery in Orange County, and is contractually obligated to remain there for four more years.

Unfortunately for reviled Angels owner Arte Moreno, Trout is just about the only thing worth paying attention to on an 18-34 team that hasn’t reached the playoffs since 2014. Not even generational talent Shohei Ohtani could get the Halos over the hump during his six seasons with the team, and baseball's unicorn finally jumped ship for the crosstown-rival Dodgers.

The Angels are not good now, and they’re not going to be good at any point in the near future. Their farm system has consistently ranked among the worst in baseball, and a developmental emphasis on rushing prospects up to the majors has resulted in a few decent contributors like Nolan Schanuel and Zach Neto, but zero starpower to pair with the greatest player in franchise history.

It’s safe to assume that Moreno would be loath to trade away Trout, just like he doggedly refused to entertain the idea of flipping Ohtani even when his departure was imminent. However, it just might be possible that the most hated man in Angels history makes sure not to repeat that mistake, and gives the green light to a Trout trade in what could be the last opportunity to do so.

For Moreno and the Angels there is a real possibility that another injury or a simple drop-off in performance makes Mike Trout a truly untradeable asset, no matter how much respect his name still commands. The 34-year-old is playing at an elite level at the moment, and would certainly be a risk worth taking for any team in need of an outfield bat. That calculus could change at any moment, and then the Angels are staring down the barrel of four more years of a sunk cost.

Trout would bring a franchise-altering dynamic to a Phillies club that is in desperate need of a shakeup. The team has done a remarkable job digging their way out of a seemingly insurmountable hole over the past few weeks, but the same tired, worn-out, uninspiring group of players that have failed to deliver in October for five straight years still remains in place.

The Phillies biggest needs are a potent right-handed bat and help in the outfield. They can kill two birds with one stone, and give a desperate fanbase the most electrifying jolt imaginable, with one big gamble. It may not turn out the way everyone hopes it will, but it would certainly change the narrative of “running it back”.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Loading recommendations... Please wait while we load personalized content recommendations