The Philadelphia Phillies are in disarray and it’s due to of one man's actions: Dave Dombrowski. The erstwhile president of baseball operations has made one blunder after another in constructing his disinterested, sloppy, overpaid team. The chickens have come home to roost as the Phillies sit at 13-19 on the year with just a flicker of hope to make the postseason. It’s far past time for Dombrowski to walk the plank, and his callous handling of the firing of his subordinate Rob Thomson on Tuesday confirmed just how much of a snake he can truly be.
Something needed to be done about the Phillies’ unacceptable start to the season. Despite a successful tenure that spanned five seasons as manager, Rob Thomson’s lackadaisical style had finally led to a complacent team publicly depantsing themselves day after day. Topper was shown the door, justifiably so, and replaced with legendary New York Yankee Don Mattingly.
Despite the dramatic shakeup at the helm, the change didn’t go far enough, as the head of the snake still remains: Dave Dombrowski. The woefully inadequate roster that he assembled has failed to perform, littered with expensive, ill-advised contracts and once-promising homegrown players whose development has stalled out.
Dave Dombrowski handed Rob Thomson a plate full of garbage and tasked him with preparing a five-star meal. Topper made his fair share of mistakes crafting the dish, but the truth is it was never going to work out even if he had been perfect.
Tuesday’s press conference gave Phillies fans an intimate look at the man pulling the strings throughout the organization, and it was not a flattering one. The future Hall of Fame executive threw others under the bus in order to escape scrutiny and stuck his head in the sand regarding the problems he's created.
When asked who should be blamed for the team’s horrid start, Dombrowski beat around the bush saying, “This isn’t a blame game… we collectively are not doing well as a whole group. I don’t think we’re playing very well from an offensive, defensive, pitching performance [standpoint]. I don’t think we’re playing up to our capabilities… You can blame whoever you choose to, but for us we don’t really do that. Rob just like the rest of us, you bear responsibility.”
At first glance that may seem like a pretty standard PR-friendly answer. No one in particular should shoulder all of the blame; everyone needs to step up. However, notice who was missing from Dombrowski’s answer. He called out the pitchers that he personally selected to be on the team. Same for the position players. He name checked the manager that he promoted to the role back in 2022. The only person conspicuously missing from Dave Dombrowski’s list of suspects was his own.
Phillies' Dave Dombrowski thinks it's everyone's fault but his
Dombrowski seems to think that he hasn’t made a single misstep in assembling the 2026 Phillies. Not even God Himself could field a better 26-man squad. In fact, Dombrowski made sure to let himself off the hook later in the press conference. The 69-year-old was asked directly if he had any regrets about his construction of the Phillies’ roster and answered, “No, I don’t have any regrets.”
Well, it doesn’t get any clearer than that. Dave Dombrowski believes the Phillies’ roster is perfect just the way it is, and if something is wrong it is the fault of Rob Thomson, the players, the grounds crew, the janitors, and anyone else not named Dave Dombrowski. The man is either completely delusional, or omitting his own colossal mistakes to save his own skin.
That was just the beginning of Dombrowski’s heel turn, as he went on to publicly admit going behind Thomson’s back to court another potential manager. When probed on whether or not he had attempted to hire recently-fired Boston Red Sox skipper Álex Cora, Dombrowski flatly stated, “I talked to him on Sunday morning. We talked about potentially taking the job… I had told him I had really come to the conclusion at that point that if he took it I was going to make a change.”
Dombrowski explained that Cora declined the offer in order to spend time with his family, but that he would have hired Cora if given the chance. One interesting factoid on Álex Cora: he was suspended for a year due to his role as one of the ringleaders of perhaps the worst cheating scandal in baseball history, and carried over that same unethical style to his tenure in Boston (under Dombrowski's watch). It seems integrity was not at the top of Dombrowski's wishlist in looking for a new manager.
Just to clear up the timeline, Rob Thomson wasn’t fired until Tuesday, and yet his boss was courting replacements for him days before. That's like a husband cruising Tinder for his next date before even doing his wife the courtesy of telling her it’s over. As Michael Corleone so eloquently put it: it’s not personal. It’s strictly business.
And yet, it feels just a tad bit personal after Dombrowski made a public display of humiliating his players and their skipper. During last weekend’s disastrous series against the division-rival Atlanta Braves, Dombrowski invited three of his most trusted scouts to snoop inside the dugout and clubhouse, looking for any dirt they could find. This may have been mere information gathering, but the public spectacle of it seemed to be more of a show of dominance than a true search for answers.
Dombrowski decided to get personal with his players as well, heaping blame onto Alec Bohm, Adolis García, and all of his other failed cleanup hitter experiments, claiming, “Nobody’s performed as a cleanup hitter. We’ve had people who have performed in the past as a cleanup hitter. They’re not doing that right now.”
While that statement is certainly accurate, Dombrowski conveniently left out the fact that a blind man could have seen that the lineup lacked any semblance of power outside of Bryce Harper and Kyle Schwarber. And still, Dombrowski rolled out a collection of bubble gum and duct tape in the four-hole and is seemingly astonished that it hasn’t worked out. The man is the walking embodiment of “we’ve tried nothing, and we’re all out of ideas.”
The absurdity of Dombrowski’s tenure has caused the fanbase to place a bullseye directly on his back, and yet he seems to pay no mind to legitimate concerns about his ability to pilot the Phillies to a World Series victory. He was asked why fans should believe he’s still the right man for the job and condescendingly responded, “You can answer that question. I’m not gonna get into that.”
When the topic is the Phillies’ manager, cleanup hitter, pitching staff, or anyone else, Dave Dombrowski has no qualms about sharing his opinion on how poor of a job they’ve done. However, as soon as the focus shifts to his own job performance, all of a sudden he’s above the fray.
Dave Dombrowski is not such a lowly man as to have his decisions questioned by peasants. That dishonor belongs to his underlings like Rob Thomson. If fans can’t figure out how blessed they are to have a genius like Dave Dombrowski at the helm, then maybe they should just sit in the corner and think about what they’ve done. If they don’t know what they did wrong, Dave Dombrowski is certainly not going to tell them.
Dave Dombrowski should take some lessons in accountability from Rob Thomson
This holier-than-thou persona is in direct contrast to the down-to-earth, humble man that he just nailed to a cross to serve his own needs. After his firing on Tuesday, Thomson made himself available to the media, something highly unusual for a man in his position. Thomson’s stated reason for doing so was to be accountable, something Dave Dombrowski could learn a thing or two about. In fact, Topper used that time to tell reporters that he had no hard feelings towards Dombrowski for his handling of the situation, even in light of the Cora infidelity.
Rob Thomson is a stand-up guy who took ownership of the group of men that he led and their poor performance. In contrast, Dave Dombrowski thre a good man to the wolves to save his own skin.
The Phillies have become a laughingstock not because of Rob Thomson’s in-game decisionmaking, but because of Dave Dombrowski’s complete mismanagement of the roster. Rob Thomson was far from perfect, but he’s a decent, honorable man who led the franchise to heights that hadn’t been reached in over a decade, and gave Phillies fans memories they’ll cherish for a lifetime.
Dave Dombrowski has time and again made colossal missteps that hamstring not just the Phillies’ current ability to compete for a championship, but their future prospects as well. When the situation degraded to the point of someone getting the axe, Rob Thomson fell on his sword with dignity, while Dave Dombrowski slithered away to hand out his next onerous contract.
Rob Thomson will be missed by any Phillies fan who values honesty, transparency and decency. Whenever his reign ends, Dave Dombrowski will leave behind a legacy of dysfunction and failure.
Add us as a preferred source on Google