Skip to main content

3 potential J.T. Realmuto trades Phillies could make as catching fears grow

A goodbye to the former BCIB?
ByChristopher Babos
Sep 29, 2026; Cumberland, Georgia, USA;  Philadelphia Phillies catcher J.T. Realmuto (10) slides safely after hitting a triple in the seventh inning during game one of the Wildcard round for the 2026 MLB Playoffs at Truist Park.  Mandatory Credit: Dale Zanine-Imagn Images
Sep 29, 2026; Cumberland, Georgia, USA; Philadelphia Phillies catcher J.T. Realmuto (10) slides safely after hitting a triple in the seventh inning during game one of the Wildcard round for the 2026 MLB Playoffs at Truist Park. Mandatory Credit: Dale Zanine-Imagn Images | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

The Philadelphia Phillies are exploring available options to improve their lineup heading into the 2027 season. While it might seem counterintuitive on the surface, Philly could set the entire lineup up for an overhaul if the franchise decided to trade away starting catcher J.T. Realmuto.

The Phillies seemed willing to let Realmuto go as a free agent during the 2025 offseason, but ultimately re-signed the catcher after Bo Bichette’s stunning decision to sign with the New York Mets. The veteran signed a 3-year, $45 million contract and now has two years remaining.

Realmuto, 35, responded to his new contract with a subpar 2026 campaign. He finished with a .205 batting average and 85 hits, a significant drop from his 129 base knocks from the 2025 campaign. Realmuto posted a 0.0 bWAR for the first time since his initial taste of professional baseball, an 11-game sample size with Miami in 2014. 

A change-of-scenery trade for Realmuto could give another franchise an experienced catcher who could help a rising prospect navigate the early stages of his career, leaning on his 12 years of experience behind the plate.

The available free agent options could leave some teams searching for a more reliable option behind the dish. The Phillies should reach out to a few different teams to explore moving their starting backstop.

3 teams who could be interested in a veteran backup catcher

The Chicago White Sox could be a potential trade partner for Philadelphia. Chicago’s South Side squad features 24-year-old Kyle Teel. The White Sox backstop dealt with lower-body injuries during the 2026 regular season, which limited him to 39 games. With Joey Bart, age 29, as the other masked man on the roster, Realmuto would provide veteran leadership to a clubhouse featuring just one other position player (Andrew Benintendi) over 27 years old.

Pedro Pages, 27, has been a serviceable catcher during his three seasons with the St. Louis Cardinals, but he is likely to lose his starting spot to 22-year-old rookie Leo Bernal. The seventh-ranked backstop on the 2026 edition of MLB’s Prospect Rankings finished with a .284 batting average with 27 hits on 102 plate appearances across his first 24 big-league ballgames. If the Cardinals wanted to invest in the future of their young catcher, it would make a ton of sense to look at Realmuto, with over a decade of big-league ballgames under his cleats.

The last thing the San Diego Padres need is another catcher. Seriously. With Freddy Fermin, Luis Campusano, and rookie Ethan Salas on the big-league roster, there isn’t much room on the West Coast. However, if the Friars decide to move one of their right-handed-hitting catchers, Fermin or Campusano, that could allow a veteran like Realmuto to join a loaded squad featuring Fernando Tatis Jr., Manny Machado, and others.

Without Realmuto on the roster, the Phillies could look into the available backstops on the market. Ryan Jeffers received a qualifying offer from the Minnesota Twins, so he would cost draft-pick compensation in addition to cash. A right-handed-hitting catcher, such as Carson Kelly or Tyler Stephenson, could provide additional flexibility for Don Mattingly’s lineup.

Realmuto has 10-and-5 rights, meaning he can veto any trade since he has at least 10 years of MLB service time and has spent five consecutive seasons in Philadelphia. While that doesn’t entirely restrict which other clubs he could be traded to, it could affect those discussions, since Realmuto can disrupt trade talks if he is not fond of the destination. 

The catching position might not be an immediate need for the Phillies in 2027, but it could quickly become a problem if the organization doesn’t figure out who will take over once Realmuto’s days as a Phillies catcher are over. After a tough 2026 campaign, that time could come sooner than most Phillies fans think.

Add us as a preferred source on Google