Roy Halladay already had a Hall of Fame résumé when he was acquired by the Philadelphia Phillies in December 2009. The six-time All-Star and 2003 AL Cy Young Award winner was coming off a 2.79 ERA season, having pitched 239 innings in 2008. And despite that fantastic season, there was still some mild trepidation about Halladay in Philly.
After trading for the former Cy Young winner, Phillies general manager Ruben Amaro Jr. turned around and traded Cliff Lee to the Seattle Mariners the very same day on orders from ownership. The team had lost its World Series hero in exchange for the future Hall of Famer. Luckily, for Amaro, Halladay quieted every doubter.
In 2010, he authored one of the greatest pitching seasons in club history, throwing 250.2 IP with nine complete games and four shutouts to a 2.44 ERA. His 8.5 WAR led the National League, and his May 29 perfect game in Miami solidified him as the best pitcher in the sport.
15 years ago today, Roy Halladay etched his name in MLB history by throwing the 20th perfect game EVER 😤
— MLB (@MLB) May 29, 2025
Halladay dominated throughout the 2010 season, unanimously taking home the NL Cy Young Award, leading the league in:
IP (250.2)
W (21)
CG (9)
Shutouts (4) pic.twitter.com/lQQU8ldw7s
Just over four months later, Halladay would nearly repeat the feat on an even bigger stage, hurling a no-hitter against the Cincinnati Reds in his first-ever postseason game. The only blemish on his line was a fifth-inning full-count walk to Jay Bruce.
The Phillies have not won another Cy Young Award since Halladay in 2010
For his efforts that year, Halladay was unanimously awarded National League Cy Young honors on this day, 16 years ago, in 2010.
He beat out second-place Adam Wainwright, who had a lower ERA by two points, but pitched only 230.1 innings. What a difference 16 years makes. In 2026, the Major League leader in innings was Sandy Alcantara with 214.
Since 2010, no Phillies pitcher has won a Cy Young Award. The team has had five runner-up finishers: Halladay, 2011; Zack Wheeler, 2021; Wheeler, 2024; Christopher Sánchez, 2024; Sánchez, 2025. The Phillies have grown accustomed to being the bridesmaid, never the bride.
Halladay, for his part, nearly repeated the feat in 2011, when he lowered his ERA by nine points to 2.35 and led MLB in FIP at 2.20. Unfortunately, Clayton Kershaw had his breakout season and outpitched Halladay en route to his first Cy Young Award as the face of the next generation of Hall of Fame hurlers.
Halladay passed away seven years later, on November 7, 2017. He is mourned as a father, a coach, and one of the greatest pitchers to ever wear a Phillies uniform.
