This Phillies-Padres Mason Miller mock trade package could powerfully solve bullpen woes

Now is the time for the Philadelphia Phillies to push all their chips on. Looming labor unrest threatens to derail next season, while the club’s aging core is running out of time to finally win a World Series. With the future far from guaranteed, the Phillies need to pull out all the stops at this year’s trade deadline to upgrade their roster. Perhaps the best way to do that would be selling the farm to reel in generational closer Mason Miller. Let’s dive into what that trade would look like, and how it would impact the Phillies. 

The San Diego Padres acquired Miller (and back-end starter JP Sears) from the homeless Athletics at last year’s deadline for a king’s ransom. Gunslinging general manager A.J. Preller made the A’s an offer they couldn’t refuse starting with top-5 prospect in baseball Leodalis De Vries, as well as other well-regarded youngsters Braden Nett, Henry Baez and Eduarniel Nuñez. 

Things haven’t gone well for the Friars since then, as they were bounced in last year’s Wild Card round and currently sit two games out of a playoff spot in a cluster with a middling 53-53 record. That rough performance, coupled with a bottom-of-the-barrel farm system, has led to plenty of speculation that Miller could be on the trade block to jumpstart a retool, with ESPN’s Jeff Passan going so far as to say the two-time All-Star is “definitely available.”

As was the case last summer, Miller is certainly not going to be dealt for anything less than a gargantuan haul. Preller may not be able to net quite the same consensus top prospect this time around, but multiple top-100 prospects or something close to that should be the bare minimum. The question is, can the Phillies put a package like that together?

The Phillies' farm system is a tragic state of affairs. Years of horrible drafting, criminal mismanagement of resources and stalled development have left the minor league ranks a smoldering ruin, with Baseball America slotting the franchise in at second-to-last in their updated rankings. And yet, they may have just enough to make it work.

President of baseball operations Dave Dombrowski will enter the Hall of Fame one day with a reputation as a gambler who was willing to mortgage the future to win in the present, and yet he hasn’t done that in his six seasons in Philadelphia. Now is the time to strike, and three-and-a-half years of Mason Miller may be worth selling the farm for.

The Phillies will need to gut their farm system to convince the Padres to part with Mason Miller

2021 first-rounder Andrew Painter was once the top pitching prospect in all of baseball, but injuries and ineffectiveness have dampened his star significantly in recent years. Still, at just 23 years old he’s far too young to give up on, and the ace upside that he showed early on may still be enough to headline a trade package.

To ease Preller’s concerns about Painter’s future, Dombrowski would need to add in rising young star Gage Wood, whose elite fastball and proximity to the majors has gotten him all the way into the top-50 prospects in the game. The 22-year-old could step into a high-leverage relief role today, but the Phillies have been developing him as a starter this year with good results, and see front-of-the-rotation status in his future.

While Painter and Wood are already a lot to part with, there’s no chance the Padres would be satisfied with just that. Miller is controllable via arbitration for three seasons after this year, and has Hall of Fame talent. Another prospect with superstar upside is needed in this package, and that could be 17-year-old phenom Francisco Renteria.

The Venezuelan outfielder signed for $4 million earlier this year, and has a legitimate five-tool skill set. The Athletic’s Matt Gelb claimed that Renteria is as close to an “untouchable” prospect as the Phillies possess, but no one should be untouchable in pursuit of Mason Miller.

Rounding out this enormous haul would be a ready-made bullpen replacement in Orion Kerkering. The 25-year-old has wipeout stuff and is a key component of the Phillies' pen, but his season-ending blunder last October may ultimately prove to be more than he can overcome to reach his ceiling and a change of scenery could do him a world of good. He’s no Miller, but he would give San Diego a very talented arm to slot into the back end of their bullpen.

Parting with a quartet of players this talented would lay waste to a Phillies farm system that has very little to begin with. If Dombrowski really wanted to play hardball he could try to coax Preller to throw in another useful piece like veteran starter Walker Buehler or mashing first baseman Ty France to even the scales just a tad. Still, whatever way it’s sliced, this would be an overpay by the Phillies.

And yet, overpays can be worth it. A one-two punch of Mason Miller and Jhoan Duran would effectively turn every playoff game into a seven-inning affair, as opponents would be looking for miracles trying to score late in games. One dominant closer doesn’t fix all of the Phillies’ problems, but there may not be a top-tier right-handed bat available this summer and an elite starting pitcher like Tarik Skubal would be a luxury, not a need.

Bringing in Mason Miller would by no means guarantee Phillies fans the World Series victory they so richly deserve, but it might be the one thing that moves the needle furthest in that direction. With sand running out of the hourglass and the future very much up in the air, pushing all of their chips into the center of the table could be the best path forward for the Phillies.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow