Skip to main content

Phillies protect breakout prospect from Rule 5 Draft with roster spot ahead of deadline

The Phillies are choosing ther safe path.
ByBen Silver
Reading infielder Bryan Rincon (4) dives back into first base during the home opening day game against Akron, April 2, 2026, in Akron, Ohio.
Reading infielder Bryan Rincon (4) dives back into first base during the home opening day game against Akron, April 2, 2026, in Akron, Ohio. | USA TODAY Network via Reuters Connect

The Philadelphia Phillies decided to protect only one player from the Rule 5 draft in 2026. Bryan Rincon, the 2026 Paul Owens Award winner, who had a breakout season at Double-A Reading, was added to the 40-man roster hours before the 6 p.m. deadline.

According to Destiny Lugardo of PhilliesNation, Rincon will be the only player added to the 40-man. That means Wen-Hui Pan and Mavis Graves will remain unprotected. Both are likely to be selected if the Rule 5 draft is held this year, but with the owners planning to begin a lockout at midnight on December 2, that seems unlikely.

The Rule 5 draft is held annually at the MLB Winter Meetings, scheduled this year for December 7-10 at the Manchester Grand Hyatt in San Diego, CA. Because the meetings fall after the lockout deadline, they will be canceled unless the CBA negotiations are resolved faster than anyone expects.

The last time such a lockout occurred, in 2022, the Rule 5 draft was never rescheduled. This means that teams who protected players from the draft need not have done so. But since negotiations are expected to be far uglier in 2026-27, possibly going up to, or even into, the regular season, additional problems arise.

Bryan Rincon won't be able to participate in minor league action if the lockout continues into the regular season

If the lockout cancels Major League games, the minor leagues will still continue, since they are not covered by MLBPA’s CBA. The problem therein is that Rincon, or any prospect now signed to an MLB contract on the 40-man roster, will be unable to participate in minor league games.

It could mean a whole lot of lost development time for Rincon, which is perhaps why the Phillies chose not to protect Graves or Pan. They assume, like the rest of the league, that the Rule 5 draft will be canceled, but since Rincon is such a highly touted prospect, they chose to protect him anyway. If the CBA were resolved in an edge-case scenario, or the draft was rescheduled, losing Rincon would be a disaster. If Pan or Graves were selected by another team, that would be easier to stomach.

The Phillies also chose not to protect another slew of draft-eligible players unlikely to be selected: Aroon Escobar, Kehden Hettiger, Keaton Anthony, Juan Villavicencio, and Raylin Heredia.

The Phillies' 40-man roster now has 39 players. Felix Reyes, Gabriel Rincones Jr., Moisés Chace, Andrew Hoffmann, and Alan Rangel are the other rookie-eligible players on the roster who won’t be able to compete in minor league games next year if the lockout postpones the Major League season.

Add us as a preferred source on Google