Phillies Spring Training Position Preview: Catchers

The Phillies have created a very interesting situation at one of the most important positions on the field.

For the first time in a decade, the Philadelphia Phillies will open a season without one of the most important pieces to the team’s success. Carlos Ruiz will be all the way across the nation playing with Seattle when Spring Training begins in ten days. Now, to be fair, the job was not his last season, but the idea of not having Chooch in the clubhouse is a difficult pill to swallow.

With the starting job all but sealed, the Phillies do have a nice amount of depth at the catcher position. Thanks to some creativity this offseason, the Phils will have five catchers with a legitimate shot at the big-leagues this camp. While teams normally only bring two backstops up north with them to start the season, the Phils very well could decide to bring three back to Philadelphia.

As the preseason is set to get underway in just under ten days, the catching situation is still a blurred line. While it seems the starting position is locked down, there are many questions that will soon be answered.

The Starter: Cameron Rupp

Cameron Rupp was a nice surprise during the first half of the 2016 baseball season. As the Phillies began the season, the hope was that Rupp would be a sufficient enough bridge until one of Andrew Knapp or Jorge Alfaro progressed to be big-league ready. Rupp did the organization one better though.

During the first four months of the season, Rupp was playing at a level that far exceed the expectations of the Phils and fans. Heading into the All-Star break, the 28 year old was slashing .287/.329/.507, but when the break ended, Rupp’s season started to subtly decline.

More from That Balls Outta Here

• Phillies-Mets owners’ rivalry grows after shocking Carlos Correa deal
• Could Rich Hill become ‘Jamie Moyer 2.0’ in Phillies rotation?
• Does Bailey Falter have a future in Phillies’ rotation?
• Prospect Andrew Baker could help Phillies bullpen in 2023
• Bryce Harper’s absence should lead to Phillies lineup tinkering

In the second half, Rupp put up a .211/.274/.378 line. The .184 point drop in his OPS obviously points to a decline in production. In addition, Rupp struck out in nearly 30% of his official at bats on the season. That number is way too high for a guy the Phillies are counting on to catch a bulk of their games in 2017. Defensively, he only threw out 27% (17/62) of base stealers, but only allowed 6 passed balls on the season.

However, a closer look at some other stats point to some areas of improvements. For example, Rupp nearly doubled his walk output.

Yes, it was a weak 9 walks in the first half to 15 walks in the second (24 total), but there is a glimmer of hope that he could build on the patience. Rupp showed the power potential that was seemingly his biggest strength when he launched 15 homers this season. The number ranked him ninth among catchers starting more than 100 games.

Rupp is an interesting case and will more than likely continue to be seen as the bridge for what is to come. He did a nice job handling a young pitching staff during his opportunities in 2016, and the Phils hope he will continue to provide that piece to the puzzle for at least part of 2017.

Internal Options: Andrew Knapp

Andrew Knapp is the catcher in this group of five that I am most interested in following as 2017 gets underway. He has long been thought of as a bat first type of player. While most people seem to believe that Knapp is walking into a backup catcher position, the argument can be made for him to play a different role in 2017.

The Phils originally took the 25-year old in the second round of the 2013 draft. He played in college at University of California, Berkeley. The Phils liked Knapp because they saw an advanced bat that may be able to move quickly through its system. He did just that.

The switch hitter’s ability at the plate has led him to the opportunity he sees in front of him this spring. His best season was split between Clearwater and Double-A Reading in 2015 (.308/.385/.491 with 13 homers and 84 RBI). Last year’s promotion to Lehigh Valley was met with some challenges, but Knapp was able to overcome and be a steady bat (.266/.330/.390).

Knapp’s best chance to play at the big league level is through his bat. The 107 strikeouts (24% of his plate appearances) have to be cut down if he wants to find consistent playing time. He has a strong gap stroke that will not lead to much power output (max 12-15 homers), but should bring a ton of doubles.

His defense behind the plate, albeit improved, leaves something to be desired. While he has played some first base, he is not skilled enough at the position to change completely. However, it does add to his flexibility as a professional player, which could lead to quite a unique spot for the soon to be rookie.

The Phillies have a ton of positional flexibility on their roster. With the flexibility of Howie Kendrick and Andres Blanco, and five outfielders, the Phils could very well carry three catchers. Knapp, who has the ability to hit both righties and lefties equally well, could catch a few times a month, play first base against a tough righty every once in awhile, but mainly focus on the idea of pinch hitting in major spots.

While it seems like an odd spot to take on a big league roster, the Phils could turn Knapp into the next era’s Greg Dobbs/Matt Stairs role. Find him spotted playing time, but use him to mainly hit.

Internal Options: Jorge Alfaro

Let’s suppose Jorge Alfaro maxes out his potential when he arrives in Philadelphia. What does that mean for the Phillies? Well, simply put, it will mean they have one of the best catchers in baseball. When the Phils traded for the powerful catcher, the above is what they hoped for. The question remains as to whether or not it is what they will get.

The Texas Rangers signed Alfaro as an international free agent in 2010. Five and a half years later, the Phils swooped in on the prospect when they sent Cole Hamels to Texas. Alfaro came back in a package with four other Texas prospects. However, he is the player the Phils are heavily counting on moving into the next generation of Phillies baseball.

On the diamond, teams are fortified defensively up the middle of the field. Catchers, middle infielders, and center fielders are crucial to a team’s success. In 2008, it was Carlos Ruiz, Jimmy Rollins, Chase Utley, and Shane Victorino. The Phillies are hoping for Odubel Herrera, J.P. Crawford, Scott Kingery, and yes, Alfaro to be the next version of that success.

Alfaro can absolutely fit the bill defensively. He has vastly improved his receiving, and while he tends to struggle blocking pitches, it will not be an ongoing issue back there. His arm strength is superior to any catcher this organization, or possibly any other, has seen in a long time.

Offensively, Alfaro is an interesting case. After missing most of 2015 with an injury, the 23 year old took major steps forward with his bat in 2016. Alfaro did improve his walk rate throughout the course of the season. In the first two months of 2016, Alfaro walked only two times. In the next 76 games, he took 21 walks. In short, the Phils expect him to hit balls much further than his first major league hit featured above.

The low walk number should not be a surprise because he is an aggressive swinger at the plate. Alfaro’s 15 homeruns does not seem as eye-popping as Reading teammates, Dylan Cozens and Rhys Hoskins, but he was able to show power to all fields. His swing is much calmer and controlled, which allowed him to hit the ball more to the middle of the field and the other way.

Alfaro will spend most of 2017 at Triple-A Lehigh Valley. His progression will be one that Phillies fans will want to keep a very close eye on throughout the season. His path to success is key to the future in Philadelphia baseball.

External Options: Bryan Holaday

It would be a lie to say that the minor league contract of Bryan Holaday means more than simply providing depth. Holaday’s signing was just that when it happened. A fan could assume Holaday will head to Lehigh Valley to back up Jorge Alfaro for the season. However, it became confusing with a future addition to the catching stable.

The Detroit Tigers drafted the right-handed bat out of TCU in the sixth round of the 2010 draft. They took him as a close to MLB-ready product. He was not someone with a high ceiling, but came with very little risk involved. Long story short, Holaday has never broke through his cemented ceiling.

The Phillies are Holaday’s fourth team since 2012. He started with the Tigers before being traded to Texas in 2016. The Rangers would later designate him for assignment when they brought Jonathon Lucroy over in July. The Red Sox claimed him at the beginning of August.

By far, his most successful stint has been his four years in Detroit where he produced .251/.283/.340, four home runs, and 30 RBI in 108 games played. The other two stops along the way were simply as a filler for a team in need.

Defensively, the 29-year old has thrown out 28% of the 99 runners who have attempted to take a bag against him. He is not a liability behind the dish, but also provides very little that makes him stand out to the naked eye.

While the Phillies have some other options in for backup at the minor-league level, like Gabriel Lino and Lance Moore, the Phillies may be looking at Holaday as a “next man in” type if there is an injury to one of the big club catchers. Holaday is likely going to be in a competition with the other outsider for Triple-A or MLB backup.