Phillies: Who is Next in Line for a Contract Extension?

After Odubel Herrera received a five-year contract extension in December, who should the Phillies give an extension to next?

Locking your young players up to long-term deals is one of the most important aspects of a rebuild for teams like the Phillies. They handed out their first big extension December 15 when Odubel Herrera received a five-year extension from the club. He earned it after two seasons where he was worth about four wins above replacement.

However, Herrera is by no means the only player the Phillies will eventually have to lock up an extension with. There are still several players who could very well earn an extension in the coming year. Let’s examine just a few players who could wind up with a shiny new extension from the team.

Starter Aaron Nola

Aaron Nola looked the part of an effective No. 2, if not No. 1 starter through his first 25 career starts. From his debut until June 5 of this season, Nola carried a 8.85 K/9, 1.97 BB/9, 3.12 ERA, 3.39 FIP, and 1.09 WHIP. Opposing hitters had a .229 batting average – and a .280 batting average on balls in play – due to Nola’s 50.6% ground ball rate.

More from That Balls Outta Here

• Does Bailey Falter have a future in Phillies’ rotation?
• Prospect Andrew Baker could help Phillies bullpen in 2023
• Bryce Harper’s absence should lead to Phillies lineup tinkering
• Phillies rumors: Club targets Seth Lugo for possible bullpen role
• Pirates’ bizarre Vince Velasquez hype video will make Phillies fans laugh

In Nola’s last eight starts, he didn’t even look like a major-league caliber starter. He carried a 9.82 ERA and went 1-5 in that span. He suffered from some bad luck, as he allowed a .451 BABIP despite inducing ground balls 57.8% of the time.

Nola’s injury that ended his season is the biggest hurdle to a potential extension for him. He has to return from that injury healthy in 2017 before contract talks could ever start.

However, if Nola can return from that injury – and return to the numbers from the early part of his career – the Phillies would be wise to lock up Nola as well.

Like his rotation-mate Eickhoff, Nola is also arbitration-eligible after 2018.

Reliever Hector Neris

After splitting 2015 between Triple-A and the majors, Hector Neris spent all of 2016 with the big-league club and was put to the test. He pitched in 79 games and 80.1 innings, serving as Pete Mackanin’s go-to reliever when things got tight. Neris flourished in that role, striking out 11.43 batters per nine innings as he carried a 2.58 ERA.

It isn’t a stretch to say that Neris could be the closer of the future for the Phillies. The position is wide open heading into 2017, and Neris is certainly one of the favorites as we near spring training. Mackanin was hesitant to let Neris usurp Jeanmar Gomez as the closer last season, but his effective fastball-splitter combo could lead to him succeed as the closer.

The only thing that may prevent Neris from getting an extension is if the team decides Vincent Velasquez doesn’t have the efficiency to be a starter and move him to the pen. Velasquez blows away Neris in terms of stuff, so he would likely make a better closer. However, it seems that the coaching staff wants to keep Velasquez in the rotation, so Neris will have the chance to prove himself as the future closer.

Third Baseman Maikel Franco

Maikel Franco isn’t quite the same caliber of extension candidate as Eickhoff, Nola, or Neris. His 2016 season was a letdown compared to his rookie year when he hit 14 home runs and drove in 50 runs along with posting a .280/.343/.497 line in 80 games.

However, Franco may earn an extension for simply being the best option for Philadelphia at third base within the organization. Their only legitimate third base prospect is Cole Stobbe, who was just drafted in 2016 and spent the entire year at shortstop in the Gulf Coast League. Barring another prospect moving to third, Franco will be there for the next few seasons.

But wait, “What about Manny Machado?’ some may ask. While the allure of one of the top third baseman in the game hitting free agency after 2018 may be worth planning for, free agency is never an exact science. Machado could very well sign somewhere else, blowing up the team’s plans at the position in one foul swoop. Plus, it is likely Machado would command more than $30 million a year, while an extension for Franco would be much cheaper.

Next: Phillies Recent First-Round Picks Best in a Decade?

Obviously Franco has to bounce back in 2017 and show he can sustain success for a full season. If he can do that, he may earn himself a shiny new deal.