The Kyle Schwarber-Shohei Ohtani showdown we’ve been waiting for is right around the corner; it just won’t happen on the ballfield.
On Tuesday evening at 6 p.m. ET, The Baseball Insiders Podcast, co-hosted by Adam Weinrib and FanSided MLB Insider Robert Murray, will go live from the iconic Bat Vault at the Louisville Slugger Museum and Factor in Louisville, KY, to announce the winners of the Louisville Slugger Silver Slugger Awards.
Surrounded by decades' worth of Hillerich & Bradsby’s finest bats, including specimens like a Johnny Bench model with a curved handle that helped the Hall of Fame catcher redefine his career, Weinrib and Murray will announce the winners one-by-one.
The show will feature guest appearances by six previous Silver Slugger winners, including former Philadelphia Phillie Ryan Howard, as well as Albert Pujols, Anthony Rizzo, and Eric Hosmer.
The winners are decided by votes collected from four representatives from each MLB team: one manager and three coaches of the organization's choosing, and voters cannot cast ballots for players on their own club.
Why Kyle Schwarber has an edge over Shohei Ohtani in the Silver Slugger showdown
The Phillies’ only nominee this year is Kyle Schwarber. He is one of only two nominees for the National League designated hitter Silver Slugger, alongside four-time winner Shohei Ohtani.
Since signing with the Los Angeles Dodgers ahead of the 2024 season, Ohtani has taken home the honors as a shoo-in in both seasons. 2026, though, won’t be so straightforward for the two-way superstar.
Ohtani missed 27 games last year due to a myriad of injuries, and his OPS fell by a whopping 125 points from 2025. His .889 OPS is significantly better than Schwarber’s .857, but the Phillies’ slugger had 83 more plate appearances.
As the saying goes, ‘the best ability is availability,’ and Schwarber was the far more consistent performer. He had 15 more home runs than Ohtani in 2026, and while the Oshu, Japan native was a far better player overall—he had a 1.79 ERA in 85.2 innings on the mound—pitching counts for nothing in Silver Slugger determinations.
Schwarber finished runner-up in the MVP race to Ohtani last year; now is his chance for revenge. Tune in tomorrow night to be the first to find out if Schwarber comes away the victor or goes home empty-handed.
After the ceremony ends, be sure to check back in with us at That Ball’s Outta Here for all the latest analysis on the Phillies’ results.
