Phillies 2023 Report Cards: Grading the infielders

Bryce Harper, 1B

The Phillies' franchise player, Bryce Harper, was able to return to playing defense during the 2023 regular season. He had been the club's primary designated hitter since he injured his right arm in April 2022. He underwent Tommy John surgery last offseason and made a remarkable recovery to the lineup in May of this year.

Philadelphia was in need of more depth at first base following Rhys Hoskins' season-ending knee injury during Spring Training and Darick Hall's struggles and time missed due to his ailment. Harper took reps before debuting in a game at the position.

Harper split time with Alec Bohm and Jake Cave before becoming the primary player at the position by the end of the regular season. The 31-year-old will be the Phillies' full-time starter at first base, following president of baseball operations Dave Dombrowski's recent announcement at the GM Meetings, pushing Hoskins out the door.

At the plate, Harper was his reliable self with a slash line of .293/.401/.499 in 126 games played. He showed why he is considered one of the best all-around players, hitting 21 home runs, 72 RBI, 84 runs, and 134 hits in 457 plate appearances. He had 29 doubles, 80 walks, and 11 stolen bases, demonstrating his well-roundedness as a hitter.

In 13 postseason contests, he had a slash line of .285/.455/.643. The Las Vegas, Nevada native had 12 hits, 14 runs, five home runs and eight RBI. He exhibited his ability to get on base with 13 walks as well.

Harper had a relatively smooth transition defensively from right field to first base for the Phillies. He had one error in 36 starts at the infield position, along with 20 assists and 258 putouts. He did not commit any errors in 13 starts at first during the playoffs. He is certainly capable of being Philadelphia's starting first baseman, considering his relentless work ethic.

Harper remains the heart and soul of the Phillies, even during his slumps in the batter's box. He's willing to do whatever it takes for Philadelphia to succeed. If the organization wins a World Series during his time with the team, he'll undoubtedly be in the running for World Series MVP.

Grade: A-

Bryson Stott, 2B

The Phillies organization has found a special player in Bryson Stott. He has developed into a fine hitter and fielder during his two seasons in the major leagues. The second baseman followed up his rookie year with a slash line of .280/.329/.419 in 585 plate appearances during the 2023 regular season.

He received a nomination for a Gold Glove Award, which went to the Chicago Cubs' Nico Hoerner.

Stott showed his ability as a fielder with only five errors committed, which was one of the fewest among players at his position with 100-plus games started in 2023. He represents one of the key players who have helped turn the Phillies' defense around from one of the league's worst fielding clubs a few years prior.

For most of the year, the second baseman was the club's most dependable player overall in terms of his success on both offense and defense.

September was Stott's worst month hitting as he had a .181/.245/.255 line in 94 plate appearances. He had mixed results offensively in the postseason as his struggles appeared to carry over. He did have a key grand slam against the Miami Marlins in Game 2 of the Wild Card Series that helped Philadelphia advance to the National League Division Series against the Atlanta Braves.

The future is bright for the Las Vegas, Nevada native as he enters his third season in 2024.

Grade: A-

Alec Bohm, 1B/3B

Philadelphia received more encouraging development from infielder Alec Bohm in his fourth professional season.

His defensive errors decreased for the second consecutive year since he had 16 in 2021 (15 at his natural third base position) and committed 13 errors at third in 2022. Bohm had a stark improvement with only four errors at third base this year but looked uncomfortable at times playing first base, with five errors.

He played the most time at first base (80 appearances, 59 starts) than in any of the previous three seasons. Unless injuries strike the Phillies at first base again, the 27-year-old should see far less time at the position and more playing time at third base in 2024.

The 2018 third-overall selection by Philadelphia had a .274/.327/.437 line in 558 at-bats during the regular season. He set a career-high with 31 doubles, 20 home runs, 97 RBI, and 42 walks. However, like Stott, he had his least productive hitting month of the season during September, slashing .235/.278/.412 in 102 at-bats.

Bohm's offensive struggles continued during the playoffs. He had a .239/.340/.370 line but had a minimum of one hit in six of the seven contests in the NLCS. While many of the hitters struggled in Games 6 and 7 against the Diamondbacks, the third baseman had three hits, one walk, and two runs scored in eight plate appearances.

He may have his best season yet in 2024.

Grade: B

Trea Turner, SS

The Phillies front office made arguably the biggest signing in free agency last offseason with the addition of Trea Turner. His presence ranked as the organization's second biggest signing following the addition of Harper in February 2019. Fans and the team viewed the addition of the shortstop as the missing piece that would put Philadelphia over the top to win a World Series.

However, Turner endured his struggles in his first season with the Phillies. 2023 was his least productive year offensively as a starting shortstop. He had a .266/.320/.459 line with a career-high 150 strikeouts in 639 at-bats. The 30-year-old infielder had a tough year in the field with a new career-high in errors (23) in 153 games. His .960 fielding percentage was one of the lowest of his career.

Following a standing ovation from Phillies fans before his first at-bat during a contest in August, Turner managed to salvage his season to a degree. His .333/.376/.685 (August) and .299/.364/.567 (September) lines were the sort of production expected from him offensively.

Turner's .347/.400/.643 line in 13 postseason contests was solid, but the shortstop faded down the stretch as he went 0-for-12 in Games 5-7 of the NLCS. The Phillies missed his success offensively, particularly in Games 6 and 7 against the Diamondbacks. His four errors in 13 contests were the most he committed during his career in the postseason as well.

The shortstop will be motivated for a much improved second season offensively and defensively with the Phillies in 2024. Philadelphia signed him to a massive contract (11-year, $300 million) last offseason. Turner needs to have a much better season next year, or this deal could begin to look like a terrible decision by the front office.

Grade: C

More Philadelphia Phillies news and analysis