Phillies letting Ranger Suárez walk looks even worse after Red Sox breakout

It didn't come as a surprise this offseason when the Philadelphia Phillies' front office decided to prioritize the bats over the starting rotation. With a surplus of talent headlining the Phillies' pitching staff, most notably Cy Young finalists Zack Wheeler and Cristopher Sánchez, there seemed to be too many cooks this past offseason; Aaron Nola, Jesús Luzardo, Andrew Painter, Taijuan Walker, and then-free agent Ranger Suárez were all theoretically vying for the remaining three starting roles.

On the flip side, when the Boston Red Sox lost out on the Alex Bregman sweepstakes, they chose to then pivot from assessing their needs to adding more starting pitching to their already deep rotation. In January of this year, Boston offered Suárez a five-year, $130 million contract, an offer the Phillies just could not counter. There was no justification for spending that much on the team's starting pitching, given how much depth Philadelphia already had.

Now, a full month into play, the Phillies' starting rotation is still one of the worst in baseball, and after a few rocky starts in his new home city, Ranger Suárez is looking as though he's back to his true Philly form after having "one of the best starts of his career," according to the Venezuelan pitcher.

With Ranger Suárez finding his footing, did the Phillies make a mistake in letting him go?

Because the Phillies offered Suárez a qualifying offer that he rejected, they received a draft pick as compensation for losing the lefty, who'd previously spent all 13 of his professional seasons in the Phillies organization. Unfortunately, not even an additional draft pick can fill the void of a prodigal son lost.

Anyone who knows Ranger's quirks from his Phillies tenure knows that it usually takes the southpaw a few games to get into the season. For example, in 2025, Suárez started the season on the injured list with lower back stiffness. He made his debut in May against the Arizona Diamondbacks, where he gave up seven earned runs over just three and two-thirds innings.

After that start, however, Suárez reverted to the strong groundball pitcher the Phillies knew and loved. After two rocky starts to begin his Red Sox career, it seems as though he's back to his old ways. Meanwhile, the Phillies continue to flounder in every way imaginable, especially the rotation, with the Phillies' Suárez replacement(s) of
Jesús Luzardo and Aaron Nola pitching subpar at best.

Suárez began the 2026 season with an 8.31 ERA (earned run average) and an 8.44 FIP (fielding independent pitching), but since March 30, his first Red Sox start, he's managed to bring himself down to a 3.09 ERA and a 3.36 FIP, numbers that will continue to diminish as the season goes on.

If you were to put Ranger Suárez's current season stats in the mix with the mess that is the Phillies current team numbers, his 3.09 ERA would significantly lower the Phillies rotation's abysmal 5.08 ERA. In fact, the "Ranger effect," if he were still in Philadelphia, would lower the 5.08 ERA down to a 4.30-4.50 mark, ranking them around the middle of the pack alongside the Baltimore Orioles or Minnesota Twins in terms of rotation ERA. That sounds better than fighting for one of the highest, and worst, marks in baseball.

Should the Phillies have made it work with Suárez? Who's to say? Several of Philadelphia Phillies President of Baseball Operations Dave Dombrowski's moves throughout Suárez's Phillies tenure made it clear that, despite his loyalty to the organization and his talent, Ranger would always be a second-tier pitcher in the Phillies starting rotation, rather than the stud he grew into. So, the big fish needed a bigger pond, and with each passing start, so many Phillies fans find themselves saying, "Wow, it would've been nice to back that homegrown horse over Nola," whose deal has, at this point, aged like expired milk with no real improvements on the horizon.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow