Skip to main content

Phillies GM Preston Mattingly reveals strategy pivot that could help Japanese recruitment

It'll take the perfect guy.
ByEthan Williams
Dec 9, 2024; Dallas, TX, USA; Philadelphia Phillies general manager Preston Mattingly speaks with the MLB Network at the Hilton Anatole during the 2024 MLB Winter Meetings. Mandatory Credit: Jerome Miron-Imagn Images
Dec 9, 2024; Dallas, TX, USA; Philadelphia Phillies general manager Preston Mattingly speaks with the MLB Network at the Hilton Anatole during the 2024 MLB Winter Meetings. Mandatory Credit: Jerome Miron-Imagn Images | USA TODAY Sports via Reuters Connect

The emergence of Shohei Ohtani as one of the greatest players in the history of the game has brought new eyes to Japan as a baseball hotbed. NPB stars are scattered throughout the big leagues, and plenty more are on the way. Unfortunately, the Philadelphia Phillies have yet to reap any of the fruits of the Japanese market, and general manager Preston Mattingly explained why last week.

Exactly two Japanese-born players have suited up for the Phillies at any point in their history: Tadahito Iguchi as a Chase Utley replacement in 2007 (and for four games the following year), and bench outfielder So Taguchi on the 2008 World Series-winning team. The Phillies have had an uninspiring pipeline to Asia; they've never had a Taiwanese-born player and have had only two South Koreans.

However, that hasn't been for lack of trying, at least in recent years. The club made an offer of more than $300 million to ace Yoshinobu Yamamoto ahead of the 2024 season, who landed with the Los Angeles Dodgers instead. They also showed interest in right-hander Tatsuya Imai last winter and signed hurler Koyo Aoyagi to a minor-league deal in January of 2025.

It seems the biggest Japanese fish have eschewed Philadelphia in favor of clubs with more established track records with their countrymen. The Dodgers are the most glaring example, but the New York Yankees, Chicago Cubs, and Seattle Mariners all have rich histories of Japanese talent. So what about Philadelphia makes it so difficult to sign NPB stars?

The Phillies are at a disadvantage when trying to sign Japanese players, but GM Preston Mattingly thinks it could happen with the right guy

Phillies GM Preston Mattingly attempted to answer that question in a recent podcast interview. Appearing on the High Hopes podcast with hosts Jack Fritz and James Seltzer, Mattingly was asked whether the organization believes it has laid the groundwork to finally reel in a Japanese superstar.

“You don’t just flip a switch and sign these guys,” Mattingly said. “You have to build relationships. You have to have the infrastructure in place from a scouting standpoint, from a relationship standpoint, and from a comfort standpoint when they come over here. We’ve done a lot of that to try to have that set up if we were able to land somebody.”

They may have come later than some fans would have hoped for, but the Phillies still deserve credit for doing some of the smaller things to get their foot in the door in Asian markets. While he never appeared in a game for the Major League club, Aoyagi was the first player the organization brought over directly from Japan. They’ve signed a handful of youngsters from Taiwan as international free agents in recent years, most notably top-30 prospect Wen-Hui Pan and Hao-Yu Lee. They also gave South Korean righty Chan-Min Park over $1 million earlier this year.

Add the Phillies’ financial muscle to all of that, and the pieces could be falling into place to finally net a Japanese difference-maker. And yet, they still face some major obstacles in their quest.

It appears the Phillies are trapped in a vicious cycle. Japanese players tend to prefer signing with organizations that have established track records of making their countrymen feel at home, along with other perks like direct flights to and from Japan and a smaller time difference. Since the Phillies have none of those advantages, they have a harder time attracting players, widening the gap between them and the more established markets, and on and on.

Mattingly went on to explain what he thinks could get his club over the hump.

“It’s gonna take a special player to come to Philadelphia. [I’m] just being honest. Because a lot of times some things are stacked against us, like the proximity [of Japan] to Los Angeles, and the community they have set up there… I think it’s gonna take somebody that has the mind to say, ‘You know what? I’m gonna carve my own path, and I’m gonna go where nobody else has been.’”

The Phillies can’t boast an easy transition for Japanese players to Philadelphia, and they don’t have a former Japanese Phillie on speed dial to espouse their virtues. What they can offer is the chance to be a trailblazer.

The Phillies will sign an NPB star at some point. They have too much money and a ton of interest in overseas markets. The only question is how long it will take, and who it will ultimately be.

Add us as a preferred source on Google