Skip to main content

Phillies given golden opportunity to fix roster holes following non-tender deadline

The time is now.
ByBen Silver
Sep 25, 2026; Kansas City, Missouri, USA;  Cleveland Guardians right fielder David Fry (6) rounds the bases after hitting a home run during the fifth inning against the Kansas City Royals at Kauffman Stadium.  Mandatory Credit: William Purnell-Imagn Images
Sep 25, 2026; Kansas City, Missouri, USA; Cleveland Guardians right fielder David Fry (6) rounds the bases after hitting a home run during the fifth inning against the Kansas City Royals at Kauffman Stadium. Mandatory Credit: William Purnell-Imagn Images | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

The non-tender deadline has come and gone, and though MLB organizations have made most of their decisions public, more new free agents come rolling in every minute.

With only 11 days remaining before the supposed lockout begins, Philadelphia Phillies president of baseball operations Dave Dombrowski must be deliberate in pursuing a bevy of new free agents who just hit the market.

No one is fooling themselves into thinking the players who were just non-tendered will be superstars, but many of them will be fantastic fits for the Phillies' broken bullpen or as bench pieces. Before other teams snatch them up as fr cheap fill-in options, Dombrowski should consider these players.

Four new free agents the Phillies should pursue following the non-tender deadline

David Fry is a fascinating non-tender case by the Cleveland Guardians. Perhaps the notoriously penny-pinching Dolan family—the team’s owners—didn’t offer Fry a contract as a cost-cutting measure, but he should draw interest from many clubs.

Fry has serious positional versatility. Last year, he played games at catcher, first base, third base, left field, and right field. Signing him would help solve almost all the Phillies’ bench woes in one swoop. A player like that doesn’t get non-tendered for nothing, though. 

Fry slashed a paltry .201/.313/.364 last year, though his career OPS is .725. Hopefully, he’ll rebound a little bit in 2027, and the Phillies will find their backup catcher and bench outfielder solution in his bat.

As for infielders, we wrote about Nolan Gorman as a non-tender candidate several weeks ago. Lo and behold, he’s now a free agent after the St. Louis Cardinals did not extend him a contract.

Gorman was a budding star with the Cardinals after his sophomore season, but since then has hit for a .645 OPS over the last three years. He has plenty of experience at second and third base and has some serious pop in his bat, with 83 career homers.

But the Phillies’ most glaring hole is their Swiss cheese bullpen. By the end of 2026, they really struggled for depth, and James Karinchak could be an excellent bounce-back candidate.

Karinchak has pitched only 9.2 innings over the last three years, as shoulder problems derailed his promising career. In six big-league seasons, Karinchak has a 3.03 ERA over 175.1 IP. If he can find his old form, the tall righty could be a shutdown reliever at the back of the Phillies ‘pen with Alex McFarlane and Jhoan Durán.

In his limited action in 2026, Karinchak averaged 95 mph on his fastball, a better mark than his last full season in 2023. Perhaps he’s finally healthy again and ready for a full season’s workload.

Cole Sulser was one of the last men out of the bullpen for the AL pennant-winning Tampa Bay Rays. He pitched to a 4.31 ERA over 56.1 innings last year, but he has a better track record than just 2026.

Sulser has a 3.49 ERA over the last three years and had a 3.63 FIP in his action last year. He was at the mercy of some tough batted-ball luck and should rebound in 2026. At the very least, he’d be a good mop-up option for the Phillies.

Add us as a preferred source on Google