Skip to main content

Phillies legends appear on Hall of Fame ballot, but what are their chances of getting inducted

Remember these guys?
ByEthan Williams
Aug 1, 2019; Philadelphia, PA, USA; Philadelphia Phillies starting pitcher Jake Arrieta (49) throws a pitch during the first inning against the San Francisco Giants at Citizens Bank Park. Mandatory Credit: Bill Streicher-USA TODAY Sports
Aug 1, 2019; Philadelphia, PA, USA; Philadelphia Phillies starting pitcher Jake Arrieta (49) throws a pitch during the first inning against the San Francisco Giants at Citizens Bank Park. Mandatory Credit: Bill Streicher-USA TODAY Sports | USA TODAY Sports

Winter is a rough time for baseball fans; we wait months for our favorite sport to resume. This offseason could be even worse, as a contentious labor negotiation threatens to postpone, or even cancel, the 2027 MLB season. However, the baseball world isn't entirely on hold. This year’s MLB Hall of Fame ballot was released on Monday, with three former Philadelphia Phillies among the newcomers. 

The most accomplished of the trio of former Phillies is starting pitcher Jake Arrieta. Once a top prospect with the Baltimore Orioles, it wasn’t until he was traded to the North Side of Chicago that Arrieta made good on his potential. The massive right-hander won a Cy Young Award in 2015 with the Chicago Cubs, posting a minuscule 1.77 ERA with 236 strikeouts across 229 innings.

Arrieta would go on to win a long-awaited World Series with the Cubs the following year and reached free agency after the 2017 season.  The Phillies scooped up the ace on a three-year, $75 million deal that winter, hoping he would headline a rotation that featured Aaron Nola, Vince Velasquez, Nick Pivetta, and Zach Eflin.

Unfortunately, Arrieta lost his magic once he came to Philadelphia, pitching to a middling 4.36 ERA across 352 ⅔ total frames in his four years with the team, never reaching the playoffs. He then made pit stops with the Cubs and San Diego Padres in 2021 before calling it a career. There’s no chance he’ll be inducted into the Hall. It would be a miracle for him to remain on the ballot next year; he would need at least 5% of the vote.

A trio of rebuild-era Phillies are new to this year's Hall of Fame ballot

Next up is Jay Bruce, a longtime Cincinnati Reds slugger who spent his twilight years with the Phillies. A first-round draft choice back in 2005, Bruce put together an excellent .249/.319/.470 slash line with 233 home runs over 5,002 plate appearances in the Queen City before bouncing around the league in his thirties. 

The Phillies landed Bruce in an early June trade with the Seattle Mariners back in 2019 in exchange for minor league infielder Jake Scheiner and cash. The three-time All-Star slashed just .212/.242/.494 in his 83 games in red pinstripes, and was out of the league after a ten-game stint with the New York Yankees in 2021. Like Arrieta, Bruce will be lucky to survive past year one on the ballot. 

Last, but not least among the Phillies’ first-timers is infielder Asdrúbal Cabrera. The switch-hitter is best known for his eight-year run with the then-Cleveland Indians in which he slashed .270/.331/.410 with 82 homers across 914 games. The two-time All-Star bounced around to seven more teams after leaving Cleveland, ending up in Philadelphia at the 2018 trade deadline in a deal with the New York Mets for right-hander Franklyn Kilome.

Cabrera put up an ugly .228/.286/.392 line across 49 games with the Phillies, and was out of affiliated ball after the 2021 season. Continuing the trend, Cabrera shouldn’t get much more than a cursory glance from voters this year. He has a greater chance than either of the above two at sticking on the ballot for a few years, though.

Luckily for Phillies fans, it shouldn’t be all bad news on the Hall of Fame front. 2008 World Series hero Cole Hamels will look to build on his stellar first year on the ballot, when he earned 23.8 percent of the vote. Longtime Phillie Bobby Abreu is still hanging around after receiving 30.8 percent in his seventh year. Even better, franchise legend Chase Utley appeared on 59.1 percent of ballots last time around, giving him a decent chance at induction soon, if not this year.

Add us as a preferred source on Google