Brandon Marsh's Phillies redemption won't come quickly after unbelievable gaffe

Some losses are frustrating. This one felt worse than that. April 12’s 4-3 loss to Arizona was that kind of loss. The Phillies had Andrew Painter gutting through a migraine, had a lead, and had a real chance late. But they still found a way to let the whole thing unravel with the kind of mistake that sticks to a player for a while

This wasn’t a harmless mental lapse. It was a baserunning mistake that turns a possible rally into an inning-ending gift. With runners on the corners and nobody out in the eighth, Marsh took off on a 3-1 pitch to Adolis García, never located the ball, and wound up doubled off first after Ketel Marte camped under the infield pop-up.

Rob Thomson’s explanation was pretty clear afterward: Marsh needed to peek. He never did. Bryce Harper called the whole thing what it looked like: bad baseball. 

Phillies wasted Andrew Painter’s fearless return with one crushing mental error

Marsh’s redemption will not come quickly, and that is not to say he cannot recover from this mistake. He can. Baseball always gives you another chance eventually. But some mistakes are bigger than the box score because of the timing, and the damage. This happened in a one-run game, in a late inning, right after Painter had done everything in his power to drag the Phillies to a win.

And we should talk about Painter, because that kid deserved a better ending than this. He was scratched before first pitch after waking up with a migraine and throwing up multiple times, then still decided he could help once he started feeling a little better. Instead of taking the original start, he entered in the third inning behind Zach Pop and gave the Phillies five strong innings anyway. Three hits, one run, one walk, seven strikeouts. He left with a 3-2 lead after Trea Turner’s two-run homer and Bryce Harper’s RBI double flipped the game in the sixth. That should have been the story.

Instead, the Phillies made sure the conversation got hijacked by their own sloppiness. And it was not even just Marsh. Harper got thrown out trying to stretch a single into a double earlier in the game, and the Phillies also wasted a golden scoring chance in the sixth after taking the lead. That made the eighth feel even more frustrating. This was not one isolated brain cramp. It was a series of them.

Marsh is going to wear this one, and he should, because it was an awful mistake. The Phillies finished the set losing four of five and dropped their second straight series, and losses like this are a sign that a club is playing a little too loose in the details. Hopefully, Monday's bludgeoning of the Cubs represented an official turning of the page.

Marsh probably isn’t going to leg out an infield single this week and make everybody forget this happened. The only way this fades is through cleaner baseball, better decisions, and enough winning to make this feel like an ugly footnote instead of an early-season warning sign.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow