5- Cody Asche (2013 – 2016)
Asche played four seasons in Philadelphia, but by the end of his tenure he was relegated to left field with the emergence of Maikel Franco. Asche was substandard in the field during most of his time in Philadelphia. Asche posted the league average .959 fielding percentage in 2013, Asche plummeted to .943 in 2014 and .939 in 2015 before moving to the outfield.
Asche also never flourished at the plate, posting a career best .252 average in 2014 and 12 home runs in 2015, never cracking the .700 plateau in terms of OPS. In 2016, Asche had a .213/.284/.350 line in 71 games. It was clear his time in Philadelphia was over once the season ended and he wasn’t tendered a contract in the offseason.