Advertisement

Phillies’ top pitching prospect making surprise trip to pitch in Arizona Fall League

Andrew Painter will face live hitters in game action for the first time since his Tommy John surgery.
Matt Dargan
Matt Dargan

That Balls Outta Here

Philadelphia Phillies v Minnesota Twins / Brace Hemmelgarn/GettyImages

With the minor league season now long since over, a handful of Philadelphia Phillies prospects will be headed to the Arizona Fall League which runs from Oct. 7-Nov. 15. The team previously announced that nine players would make up part of the Glendale Desert Dogs roster, which will also feature minor league talent from the St. Louis Cardinals, Los Angeles Dodgers, Cincinnati Reds, and Chicago White Sox farm systems.

A few notable names headline the list of Phillies prospects heading to the desert, with SS Bryan Rincon, OF Gabriel Rincones Jr., RHP Wen-Hui Pan, and RHP Griff McGarry all expected to participate in the fall tournament. While a pair of consensus top prospects like Justin Crawford and Aiden Miller will not be making the trek to Arizona, some exciting news that was first reported by MLB.com's Todd Zolecki about the organization's long-sidelined top pitching prospect should get Phillies fans pumped for things to come next season.

Phillies’ top pitching prospect Andrew Painter making surprise trip to pitch in Arizona Fall League

According to Zolecki, that last-minute addition is none other than No. 2 prospect Andrew Painter. His recent progress includes returning to the mound for the first time this summer after undergoing Tommy John surgery last summer. He'll now take the next step, facing professional hitters in game action for the first time since he was shut down during spring training in 2023.

Prior to undergoing surgery last season, the Phillies first-round pick in the 2019 Draft had made a steady climb up the organizational ladder, while being ranked among the top 30 best prospects in MLB from evaluators at MLB Pipeline and Baseball America. Despite not throwing a professional pitch in two seasons, respect for Painter's talent has kept him ranked within the top 50 in 2024 on both sites.

According to additional reporting from The Philadelphia Inquirer's Alex Coffey, Painter's velocity has returned to pre-Tommy John levels, with his fastball said to be regularly touching between 95-99 mph. The Phillies have been super cautious with the talented 21-year-old flamethrower, opting for a program that started with low-intensity activities, such as long tossing, to increasing his workload to include pitching on the mound in simulated games late in the season.

Andrew Painter's health is a very important factor that has a major impact on the Phillies' immediate future and beyond, with few other Phillies prospects flashing the same top-of-the-rotation potential. There was a small chance that Painter could have made his debut in 2023 with a strong spring training, so perhaps a solid and healthy showing in the Arizona Fall League could give the Phillies the confidence to give him another long look in spring training next year.

Trending on That Ball's Outta Here

Matt Dargan

Matt Dargan

Matt Dargan is a writer and contributor for the Phillies FanSided website, "That Ball's Outta Here," in addition to writing about other MLB topics on Substack. Matt was born and raised outside of Boston, and earned his degree in broadcast journalism from Suffolk University. Matt's media experience includes internships at WEEI Sports Radio and The Boston Herald. Currently based in Philadelphia, Matt enjoys watching baseball, seeing live music, and collecting vinyl records.