Larry Greene, Mitch Grueller, and Shane Watson are all the definition of busts, but each of them were also supplemental picks, thus coming late in the first round. Philadelphia received the 39th overall pick for losing Jayson Werth to Washington and took Greene one pick ahead of Jackie Bradley Jr, six picks ahead of Michael Fulmer, and 14 picks ahead of Blake Snell.
Greene, a high school bat, never played above Single-A and finished a career .224 hitter.
Grueller and Watson were late compensatory picks in the 2012 MLB Draft after Philadelphia lost Raul Ibanez and Ryan Madson in free agency. Watson was taken one pick ahead of Lance McCullers Jr. and a couple of slots ahead of Matt Olson. Grueller was taken before top catching prospect Carson Kelly and pitcher Alex Wood.
More from Phillies Draft
- Phillies Scout Bishop Eustace Standout for 2021 MLB Draft
- Phillies land Mississippi RHP Gunnar Hoglund in mock draft
- Phillies draft: Adversity no problem for RHP Carson Ragsdale
- Phillies 2020 Draft: Club signs 3rd-round pick Casey Martin
- Phillies 2020 Draft: Club inks 1st-round pick RHP Mick Abel
Another candidate could have been J.P. Crawford, once considered among the top prospects in baseball. After two injury-plagued seasons with the Phillies Crawford was shipped to Seattle for Jean Segura.
Crawford certainly falls under the more disappointing prospects in Phillies history, let alone the last decade. His bat never caught up to the greatness of his glove, and the injuries certainly didn’t help. Philadelphia would have loved for Crawford to have taken the reigns last year after trading Freddy Galvis, but it was never meant to be.
In the article that precluded the biggest first round busts, Aaron Nola was named the Phillies best first round pick of the last decade. Hopefully prospects Adam Haseley, Mickey Moniak, and Alec Bohm can someday rival Nola for that title.