Five home runs in 2009 World Series
In the midst of a great team run, the Phillies headed back to the World Series to defend their title against the New York Yankees. Ironically, the last season that Utley would play injury-free, he put on a show for the ages in the World Series.
Although the Phillies failed to repeat, losing to the Yankees in six games, Utley went on a home run tear, belting two in both games two and five. His five home runs in the series to tie Reggie Jackson for the most in a single World Series.